Revising Our Viewpoints—or—Exercising Intellectual Humility
Dive into this topic by watching the video, followed by key explanations and exercises below.
The 4th Element of intellectual humility is the ability to actually put it into practice: Revising Our Viewpoint In Light Of New Information
Remember, that intellectual humility doesn’t mean gullibility, so we don’t have to change as a result of new information. We just have to be willing to.
Even so, our own thinking patterns can often cause us to be “gullible” to bad logic, depending on the situation…
Even if you’re generally high in Intellectual Humility, a given situation can spring you out of it.
We all have weak spots and blind spots.
We all have memories and experiences that lead us to be overconfident in some areas—without us even realizing it.
Once you’ve gotten a good grasp of the other 4 elements—Respect, Lack of Overconfidence, and Ego Separation—the best way to increase your chances of always behaving with high intellectual humility in a given situation is to learn about your cognitive distortions and psychologically “prime” yourself to overcome them whether you see them coming or not.
Cognitive distortions are unhelpful patterns of thinking, or biases that prevent us from thinking clearly. They’re often very related to the fallacies we learned about in Lesson 2.9, and it’s natural to fall into them.
The most common indicators of cognitive distortions include:
All or nothing thinking
Dwelling on single points of evidence rather than all of the evidence
Disqualifying the positive
Jumping to conclusions (mind reading or fortune telling)
Magnification and minimization (making small things catastrophic and vice versa)
Reasoning through emotion rather than logic
Making things personal
You can dig deeper into the definitions of cognitive biases and distortions at this interactive website: https://yourbias.is/
And you can learn about your own cognitive distortions by taking some of the mini-quizzes at https://www.clearerthinking.org/tools-and-mini-courses.
To act with IH, you need to create psychological safety for yourself.
When you think you may not be thinking clearly, it needs to feel safe for you to change your mind, or you’ll devolve into more cognitive distortions.
It also needs to feel safe for your to express yourself.
Often, the best way to create this safety for yourself is to take some time out to breathe, think, and re-approach the conversation or situation with renewed openness and confidence in your desire to find the truth (as opposed to confidence in your opinions).
Often you will feel safer to express yourself in a smaller group or in a 1 on 1 situation, versus in front of a big group in the moment.